Personality vs Institutions: Do leaders matter?
Meet GPS’s new assistant professor, Maria Carreri, whose research in political economy looks at the role of individual political leaders in determining policy outcomes
Sept. 19, 2019 | By Rachel Hommel | GPS News
At the UC San Diego School of Global Policy and Strategy (GPS), Professor Maria Carreri is interested in political selection and its consequences – who becomes a politician and how their individual traits affect policy. Studying political economy, she feels at home in the school’s collaborative, multidisciplinary environment.
“I’m very excited about the interdisciplinary environment at GPS and how it translates into cutting edge work that is policy-relevant,” beams Carreri. “San Diego is amazing, I feel blessed. The smell of San Diego – the sea, the mountains and the plants – reminds me so much of my native home in Naples.”
Her most current work focuses on the managerial competence of executive politicians in Italy and in the U.S. With a background in economics, her research studies the policy impact of the competence of political leaders, asking whether competent politicians can offset the existence of weak institutions.
Awarded the 2018 Quality of Government Best Paper by QoG Institute, her paper “Can Good Politicians Compensate for Bad Institutions?” develops an original survey instrument to measure the competence of politicians along a novel dimension: their ability as managers of their administration.
Her innovative theory that the interaction between politician’s competence and informal institutions explains variation in policy performance is a unique contribution. Collecting data on this measure by conducting a survey of 306 mayors across all Italian regions, she hopes to expand her survey approach to her research at GPS.
“Up until recently, scholarly work on U.S. local politics was centered on the notion that local politicians are constrained,” said Carreri. “A new wave of academic studies employing quantitative methods in the study of local politics is re-evaluating this notion and it’s exciting to be part of this.”
Her research asks, if we keep constant the usual determinants of politicians’ actions –preference of voters, preference of party, etc. – do the individual traits of political leaders make a difference? Borrowing from social psychology, her paper “Economic Recessions and Congressional Preferences for Redistribution” takes a unique approach to data, moving from the competence of politicians to their personal experiences and the effect that these have on the policies they enact.
Collecting a novel dataset on the biographies of U.S. Members of Congress over the 1957-2012 period, Carreri shows that politicians who grew up during a recession are less supportive of redistribution. Her results show that recessions can create a wedge between voters and their representatives.
Eager to expand her data-driven approach at GPS, this coming academic year, she will teach Quantitative Analyses of Policy Issues, a Master of Public Policy degree capstone class, alongside Professor Gaurav Khanna. Additionally, she will be creating a new course for spring quarter on urban politics that she is excited to roll out.
“I’m very interested in local politics. As polarization in national politics increases, local governments are attracting more and more attention as the place where policy can get done,” said Carreri. “I hope to inspire this next generation of students to take action on the local level.”
3 questions with Assistant Professor Maria Carreri
What is your academic focus?
What are the real-world impacts of your research?
What skills or understanding do you hope students leave your class with?
For my urban politics class, I hope that students will understand how municipal governments profoundly impact the day-to-day of citizens and think of local governments as an exciting avenue for policy change. And, that by the end of the course they will have a better understanding of how politics and governance operate at the local level in the U.S. and across the world.
Additional democracy stories:
- A day in the life of a NCAA Woman of the Year Honoree
- Nirupama Rao defines the future of Indo-Pacific relations
- Winter reading for the bibliophile
- Alumni nominated spotlight: Booz Allen Hamilton consultant Maura Deignan
- Leading from the front
- Center for U.S.-Mexican Studies expands research on drug war and migrant crisis
- A marriage of policy and advocacy
- Decarbonizing the grid
- Sylff Fellows translate vision into reality
- Stanford study finds poor air quality responsible for one in five infant deaths in sub‑Saharan Africa
- Office hours: Associate Professor Jennifer Burney
- Class of 2018 graduates embody global citizenry and leadership
- Science Policy Fellows program nurtures effective interdisciplinary scholars
- Building cross-border relationships
- Geoengineering a greener future
- Sponsored Student Spotlight: Adnan Saygili
- Celebrating academic excellence
- Painting the picture of an MPP student’s day
- Gregory Lee looks at the future of digital health and technology
- A sustainable seafood hero
- Pass the pen: Alumnae nominated spotlight
- Campus recognizes alumni as leaders and changemakers
- Innovation in mobile technology
- Ian Johnson chronicles the rise of religion in China
- Writing the book on China’s economic policy
- Broadening horizons through international experience at BCG
- Office hours: Professor Gordon McCord
- New evening option for working professionals
- China's infrastructure investment as a development strategy
- Rethinking the war on drugs in Mexico
- Creating theoretical frameworks
- Nurturing future leaders at TechPolis
- The future is female
- Jamal Russell Black on Veridian Analytics' entrepreneurial spirit
- Love is in the air
- A day in the life of an MCEPA student
- Health and human capital
- Eduardo Porter finds journalistic inspiration at GPS
- Technology assessment at the nexus of STEM and policy
- IGCC receives coveted UC research grant
- Battery storage at the center of energy policy
- Researching how humans and the environment interact
- Office hours: Professor Ulrike Schaede
- Fighting wildfires with web based imagery
- United we dream
- Our 2017-2018 Boren Fellows
- Applying game theory to study behaviors
- Students craft views on climate change at COP23
- Molding future technical experts
- Why GPS: A niche in life
- The art of entrepreneurship
- Solar energy and pursuing the policy dream
- Social entrepreneur and first time author Ken Davenport ’90 of “The Two Gates”
- Why GPS: Discovering a passion for all things math
- Our 2017-18 Dean’s Fellows
- A Living, Learning Laboratory
- A ‘Prep Program’ for success, before day one
- Office hours: Professor Gordon Hanson
- Adding to a truly interdisciplinary academic environment
- Why GPS: Apply now and figure it out later
- Sponsored Student Spotlight: Noritoshi Kurokawa
- West Coast-Trained for a Washington, D.C. Think Tank
- Linked in Latin America
- Facilitating a ‘family affair’
- Nico Ravanilla retreats to Oxford for research
- 2016 alumni remember their first year in the real world
- Pioneering international excellence
- Research at the border: A living laboratory of transformation